Back to Policy Manual index

Barre Town Supervisory District Policy Manual

TITLE: Teaching About Controversial/Sensitive Issues     CODE: IMB


Effective citizenship is a major goal of the educational experience at Barre Town Elementary School. To achieve this purpose, students should have an opportunity to examine instructional materials reflecting a wide variety of experiences. Accordingly, guidelines within which the district’s professional staff and students can teach and learn about controversial and sensitive issues are provided in this policy.

Controversial and sensitive issues are defined as those problems, subjects, or questions about which there are significant differences of opinion, for which there are no easy resolutions, and discussions of which generally crate strong feelings among people. Although there may be disagreement over what the facts are and what they mean, subjects usually become controversial and sensitive because of the different values people use in applying the facts as known.

  1. Controversial and sensitive issues shall be handled as they arise in the classroom and shall not be avoided in order to restrict or restrain the academic freedom of either the teacher or the student.

  2. Controversial and sensitive issues shall be studied with objectivity by both teacher and students.

  3. Instructional Materials and references used in the classroom will be made available by the school and such material will meet the criteria for selection of Library & Instructional Materials (IJK).

  4. In handling a controversial or sensitive issue, the teacher shall not suppress a student’s view on that issue as long as the expression of that view is not derogatory, malicious or abusive toward other students’ views. On the other hand, one student shall not be permitted to dominate the discussion. In handling controversial or sensitive issues in the classroom, both teachers and students shall be encouraged not to determine what is right and what is wrong in certain issues, but rather to come to their own conclusions as to a particular issue after independent inquiry and parental discussion.

Students’ Rights and Responsibilities

  1. To research, study, and discuss significant issues and to reach judgments and express opinions without jeopardizing their relationships with classmates or teachers.

  2. To learn in an objective school climate which will allow them to feel free to examine any aspect of a controversial or sensitive issue.

  3. To study under competent instruction in an impartial atmosphere and have access to relevant material.

  4. To recognize that reasonable compromise often is an important facet in decision making in our society.

Teacher’s Rights and Responsibilities

  1. To be free to conduct reasonable study and discussion of controversial or sensitive issues without fear of reprisal.

  2. To maintain a high degree of impartiality.

  3. To treat controversial or sensitive topics objectively and to present alternate and/or divergent positions and opinions.

  4. To determine the degree and extent of consideration to be given to a specific controversial or sensitive issue based upon knowledge, maturity, and competence of students and class.

  5. To reveal his or her opinion to the degree appropriate (if at all). When so doing, the teacher must inform students this is a personal opinion rather than a factual and authoritative statement.

  6. To ensure an accurate, factual, and balanced presentation of materials is readily available for the student.

  7. To inform the building principal prior to the teaching of units of instruction reasonably anticipated to be controversial and/or sensitive in nature and to seek administrative guidance as needed.

  8. To inform parents prior to the teaching of units of instruction reasonably anticipated to be controversial and/or sensitive in nature and to hold, if deemed necessary, an informational meeting for parents and the public before teaching the unit in question.


Date Adopted: 11/7/83
Date Revised: 8/9/06
Legal Reference(s):
Cross References:
IJK – Instruction Material